LOADING

Type to search

Tim Mohin: Top Five Takeaways from SEC Final Climate Rule

Tim Mohin: Top Five Takeaways from SEC Final Climate Rule

SEC

Two years after proposing the rule, more than 24,000 comment letters, and a nearly three-hour meeting marked by politically charged statements, the five Securities and Exchange Commissioners voted along party lines (3-2) to approve the final rule requiring climate-related disclosures for public companies listed on US stock exchanges.

Here is the TL/DR from the 886-page document with five key takeaways:

  • Materiality rules: The SEC went back to basics by requiring companies to only disclose climate issues that are “financially material.”  The definition of financial materiality has been debated for years and was determined by a Supreme Court ruling (TSC Industries v. Northway) as “a substantial likelihood that a reasonable shareholder would consider it important in deciding how to vote or make other investment decisions.”

There is one (big) exception for physical climate risks: Companies must disclose financial impacts greater than 1% of profits before taxes (specifically, companies must disclose capitalized costs, expenditures, charges, and losses incurred).

  • Scope 3 emissions are out, but risks are still in play: Most of the coverage of the final rule has focused on exempting “Scope 3” emissions (value chain emissions) from disclosure. Although disclosure of Scope 3 emissions is not required, companies must disclose material climate risks and many of these risks occur in value chain activities (Scope 3). The SEC excluded reporting on laborious and uncertain Scope 3 emissions while keeping the focus on assessing material climate risks in the value chain (the SEC explains this point on page 91 of the final rule).
  • TCFD backbone: The framework from the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) forms the backbone of the final rule. And, because the TCFD framework is also the common denominator in shaping other major climate standards (e.g., the EU and ISSB Standards), it is a helpful starting point for companies trying to “hit the easy button” to sort out all the new requirements.
  • Phased-in approach: Recognizing the costs and burden of disclosure, this final rule maintains a phased-in approach and exempts smaller companies from some requirements. The largest companies that are first to comply must collect information from FY2025 to be reported in FY2026. The phase-in and exemptions were also applied to assurance requirements.  All of the disclosures must be made in the annual 10K filing with a notable exception: material scope 1 and 2 climate emissions can be disclosed in the company’s second-quarter 10Q filing – giving companies more time to collect and report this information.

In the graphic below, we took a crack at decoding the phase-in timeline in the SEC factsheet.

In the meantime, companies must still grapple with a litany of similar requirements – for example, the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) from Europe, the new California climate laws, and various capital market listing rules (e.g., UK, Japan, Australia, Singapore, China, etc.). While the SEC did not provide much guidance on equivalency with other similar requirements, they did reference both the CSRD and California’s climate bills, how many companies will be covered by both the SEC rules and these other rules (~3,700 and ~2,520, respectively). They concluded that complying with these other rules would provide affected companies with systems and processes to comply with the SEC rule (pages 601-611).


SEC Climate Rule Fallout

Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images

The final rule took heat from all sides of the political spectrum. Some said the bill did not go far enough, like former commissioner Allison Herren Lee, who said, “Thanks to corporate lobbying, disclosure of the very real financial risks from climate change has fallen victim to the culture wars.” Democratic Commissioner Caroline Crenshaw said, “To be crystal clear, though, this is not the rule I would have written. While these are important steps forward, they are the bare minimum.”

RELATED ARTICLE: Tim Mohin: EU Reaches Peak Sustainability?

Others like Republican Commissioner Hester Peirce, who voted against the bill, believe the SEC is exceeding their remit, saying the rule “promises to spam investors with details about the commission’s pet topic of the day, climate.” Democratic Commissioner Jaime Lizárraga took the pragmatic middle, saying the Commission should not let “the perfect be the enemy of the good.”

Despite the main headline across most news sources being the extent to which the bill was weakened, both sides will still litigate. Republican state Attorneys General are already suing, and fossil fuel companies are likely to join them, arguing the SEC exceeded their authority. On the other side, the Sierra Club and others indicated they would take legal action alleging that the final rule did not go far enough.

As an editorial comment, the final rule strikes a healthy balance between giving investors decision-useful information, reducing the cost of compliance, and mitigating litigation risk.

SEC Chair Gary Gensler invoked President Franklin Roosevelt, who signed the law authorizing the Commission, saying, “Our federal securities laws lay out a basic bargain. Investors get to decide which risks they want to take so long as companies provide ‘complete and truthful disclosure.’” Gensler went on to note that most publicly traded companies are already issuing climate disclosures roughly aligned with the SEC rule.

The litigation over this rule will take time and, in all likelihood, will be decided in the US Supreme Court. The court recently heard a case that many think will result in overturning the “Chevron Deference” – which gives deference to the executive branch agencies to interpret law. In addition, the court has recently exercised its new “major questions” doctrine related to environmental matters by restricting the authority of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).  Taken together, these cases paint a dim picture of this rule as the court challenges escalate.

This Smart Read article is contributed by Tim Mohin, Global Sustainability Leader, BCG. Every week ESG News delivers smart commentary from ESG practitioners and experts to unpack issues of the week. Submit your ESG Smart Read to editor@esgnews.com

Topics

Related Articles

LOADING

Type to search

Blog

Turkey Sets 2030 Target to Cut Aviation Emissions by 5% Using Sustainable Fuel
Green Climate Fund Approves Record $1.225B for Climate Projects
UK Launches First Onshore Wind Strategy to Double Capacity, Unlock 45,000 Jobs
Phlair, Carbon Removal AS Launch Europe’s First Large-Scale DAC and CO₂ Storage Project
ISSB Launches Major Review of SASB Standards to Strengthen Climate and Industry Alignment
IKEA to Cut 1,400 Tons of Plastic Annually with Paper-Based Fitting Bags
Salesforce Launches Agentforce to Automate Sustainability Disclosures and Unlock Emissions Insights
Terra CO2 Secures $124.5M to Accelerate Commercial Rollout of Low-Carbon Cement Alternatives
Allianz Commercial Launches Climate Risk & Resilience Platform for Businesses
EU Commission Proposes Tax Incentives to Accelerate Clean Industrial Transition
J.P. Morgan’s Kinexys Partners with S&P Global to Pilot Blockchain for Carbon Markets
Mars Achieves 1.9% Emissions Cut in 2024, Unveils $250M Sustainability Investment Fund
GRI Opens Public Consultation on Revised Labor Standards for Inclusion, Equal Opportunity
New Coalition Launches to Tax Premium Flyers for Climate Resilience and Fair Transitions
Dexter Energy Secures €23M to Expand AI-Driven Trading for Renewables and Batteries
88% of Companies See Sustainability as a Long-Term Value Driver, Morgan Stanley Report
Climeworks Secures $162M in Largest Carbon Removal Investment of 2025
Zelestra Expands Sustainability-Linked Loan to €770 Million, Backed by 11 Global Banks
EU Sets 2040 Climate Target with 90% Emissions Reduction
Microsoft Secures 1.1M Tonnes of Carbon Removals in 10-Year Deal with Hafslund Celsio
Google Signs Largest Corporate Fusion Energy Deal with Commonwealth Fusion Systems
Eni, Azimut Next Launch €100M Clean Tech Fund to Accelerate Energy Innovation
CAF Approves $5.2B for Sustainable Development
EU to Integrate Carbon Credits Into 2040 Emissions Target
SP Energy Networks Launches £1.4bn Grid Investment to Accelerate UK’s Clean Power 2030 Goals
ESMA Flags Gaps in Sustainability Disclosures, Calls for Tighter Oversight in Investment Sector
Nokia Secures €1.5B Credit Facility Tied to Scope 1–3 Emissions Reduction Targets
Swiss Climate Disclosure Law Put on Hold as EU Finalizes Sustainability Reforms
EU Commission Confirms Green Claims Directive Not Withdrawn
British Airways Signs SAF Deal with EcoCeres to Cut 400,000 Tons of CO₂ Emissions
EU, EIB Unveil €5 Billion Flexible Guarantee to Unlock Global Green and SME Investments
ESG News Week In Review: 23 June - 29 June
DBS, OCBC, and UOB Launch First Report on Nature-Related Financial Risks
Singapore Business Federation Seeks ISSB Climate Reporting Delay for Smaller Firms
Ambienta Raises €500M to Scale Europe’s Small Cap Sustainability Champions
Wolters Kluwer Launches ESG Tools for CBAM Compliance and Sustainable Financial Planning
Slovenia Raises €1B Through First Sustainability-Linked Bond
Tudor Expands Sustainability Program, Reinforces Ethical Watchmaking Goals
Eni and BMW Italia Join Forces to Advance Sustainable Mobility with Biofuels and EV Charging
Meta Secures Nearly 800 MW in New Clean Energy from Invenergy to Power Data Center Expansion
MERLIN Properties and Carbon2Nature Launch 200-Hectare Forest to Capture 160,000 Tons of CO₂
ByteDance Buys 100,000+ High-Integrity Carbon Credits from Rubicon Carbon
GRI Launches Climate and Energy Reporting Standards Aligned with Global Climate Goals
AIIB and Keppel to Mobilize $1.5B for Sustainable Infrastructure Across Asia-Pacific
UK Releases Draft Sustainability, Climate Reporting Standards Aligned with IFRS
FourTwoThree Launches to Unlock $50 Trillion SME Climate Finance Opportunity
UK Unveils Plan to Become Global Hub for Sustainable Finance, Launches Transition Plan Consultations
UK, Kenya, and Singapore Launch Government Coalition to Boost High-Integrity Carbon Markets
Frontier Secures Deal with Wild Assets for 120,000 Tonnes of Permanent Carbon Removals
Microsoft Signs 12-Year Deal with Agoro Carbon for 2.6 Million Soil Carbon Removal Credits
EU Adopts New State Aid Framework to Accelerate Clean Industrial Development Through 2030
Microsoft Signs 10-Year Deal with Anew Climate, Aurora to Secure 4.8M Forest Carbon Removal Credits
JPMorganChase Secures 50,000 Ton Carbon Removal Deal with 1PointFive
Gap, Target, and Houdini Partner with Syre to Drive Global Shift to Circular Polyester
IFRS Foundation Issues New Guidance on Climate Transition Plan Disclosures
Greenbelt Capital Closes First Fund at $1B to Accelerate Energy Transition
EU Council Pushes Major Cutbacks to Sustainability Reporting and Due Diligence Rules
L’Oréal Launches €100M Innovation Accelerator to Scale Sustainable Beauty Solutions
LEGO Marks Three Years of Near-Zero Waste to Landfill in Global Manufacturing
EFRAG Targets 50% Cut in ESRS Reporting Burden in Progress Update to EU Commission
UK Launches $3.56 B Industrial Plan to Drive Clean Energy
Virgin’s Net-Zero Targets Approved by SBTi, Signaling Bold Climate Commitment
Eni Sells 20% of Plenitude to Ares for $2.3B in Renewables
GRI Launches Machine-Readable Taxonomy to Streamline Global Sustainability Reporting
Cushman & Wakefield: ESG Ranks Among Top 2 Real Estate Priorities in EMEA and APAC
Singapore Releases Draft Guidance to Strengthen Use of Voluntary Carbon Credi
Image of black tesla cars driving in china
videocam
Deep Sky Secures First DAC Offtake Deal with Rubicon Carbon
HPCL to invest $231 million to build 24 compressed biogas plants in India
Carbon Upcycling Secures $18M to Scale Low-Carbon Cement Technology
Coldplay Cuts Vinyl Emissions by 85% with Recycled EcoRecords
La Caisse Sets $400B Climate Investment Target by 2030 Following Strong Decarbonization Gains
Octopus Energy Launches $60M Fund to Accelerate Clean Power Across Africa
Mango Becomes First Brand to Use Circulose® Since Restart
videocam
videocam
Climate Tech Partners Secures $50M+ to Back High-Growth Climate Startups
Volkswagen Bank Raises €1.5 Billion in First-Ever Green Bond to Boost EV Financing
ReGenEarth Launches £100M Green Bond to Scale Biochar Carbon Removal Tech
Eni’s Versalis Unveils Demo Plant for Breakthrough Plastic Recycling Tech ‘Hoop
EPP Rejects EU Green Claims Directive, Urges Full Withdrawal
Rubicon Carbon Launches Rated Carbon Credit Portfolio with AAport Certification from BeZero
TerraPower Secures $650M to Accelerate Advanced Nuclear Deployment
Norway Launches World’s First Full-Scale Carbon Capture and Storage Value Chain
Goldman Sachs Asset Management (GSAM) has launched the Goldman Sachs Emerging Markets Green and Social Bond Active UCITS ETF (GEMS)
Google Maps Expands Sustainable Travel Features Across Europe
Datamaran launches Core Product to Streamline ESG Risk & Reporting
SAP Secures 37,000 Tons of Carbon Removals Through Climeworks Partnership
UN Global Compact Network Appoints Former Meta ESG Head Amanda Gardiner as Executive Director
KKR Acquires Zenith Energy to Expand Off-Grid Renewable Power in Australia
Amazon Becomes First to Use Sustainable Aviation Fuel at Ontario Airport in Neste Deal
IFRS Foundation Launches Free E-Learning Modules to Support ISSB Standards Adoption
UN Global Compact Launches CMO Blueprint for SustainUN Global Compact Launches CMO Blueprint for Sustainable Growth at Cannes Lionsable Growth at Cannes Lions
France Targets Ultra-Fast Fashion with Eco-Tax, Ad Ban, and Transparency Rules
SEC Drops ESG Disclosure and Shareholder Proposal Rules as Regulatory Rollbacks Accelerate
Australia Launches Sustainable Finance Taxonomy to Guide Net Zero Investment
","session_id":"ep-sess-1760565522-2DWUNWSS","page_url":"https:\/\/esgnews.com\/tim-mohin-top-five-takeaways-from-sec-final-climate-rule\/","post_id":"25918","tracking_enabled":"1","original_referrer":"","has_embedded_content":""}; /* ]]> */